June 19, 2008

Race 4 2008 Field Report: The McCain Town Hall in St. Paul

This evening I had the privilege of of attending the John McCain town hall in Saint Paul, Minnesota’s historic Landmark Center which is just 2 blocks from the Xcel Energy Center where Senator McCain will accept the Republican nomination for president later this summer.

As a blogger, I was afforded all the privileges of any MSM member.  Immediately to my left was The Note’s Mark Halperin.  To my right, literally and figuratively, was my friend Michael Brodkorb of Minnesota Democrats Exposed — the blog that has been tormenting Al Franken so much the last few months.  In front of me was another long-time blogging acquaintenace, Ed Morrissey of Hot Air.

Governor Pawlenty gave a brief introduction to an audience that was billed as “undecided” but which was populated by many friendly faces, several of whom I recognized as long time Republicans. 

Senator McCain had returned from touring flood-ravaged areas of Iowa earlier in the day and spoke movingly of efforts to stave off the rising waters.  Turning to the political, McCain made much of Senator Obama’s announcement to opt out of public financing for the general election pointing out that Obama will be the first nominee to do so since the Watergate electoral reforms.  He also read a damning quote from Obama where the junior senator from Illinois pleged less than a year ago to “aggressively pursue an agreement with the Republican nominee to commit to public financing of the general election.”  McCain concluded his opening remarks by commiting to 1 town hall event between now and the conventions — and he clearly hoped Sen. Obama would join him in these venues.

McCain spoke broadly of “reform, prosperity and peace” as the benchmarks by which his presidency would be measured.  He struck a broadly non-partisan tone that was well-received by the audience.  Highlights included a commitment to entitlement reform, elimination of earmarks, independence from foreign oil, increased off shore oil exploration and victory in Iraq.

On the subject of Iraq, McCain outlined the criteria for being able to declare victory.  The benchmarks would be a “stable and democratic” government, reduction or elimination of Iranian incluence and Iraq becoming a model for the region. 

One questioner spoke of a debilitating and expensive illness with which her son was afflicted.  McCain encouraged people who advocate government-run health care to first go to Great Britain or Canada before embracing it.  He then turned over the microphone to a well-spoken (if not a bit technocratic) Governor Pawlenty who offered his thoughts on the reforms Minnesota has embraced.

On the topic of energy, McCain said that one of Jimmy Carter’s worst decisions was an unwillingness to reprocess nuclear fuel.  While conservatives may have misgivings with our nominee’s fixation on global warming, it is clear he will be a friend to nuclear energy.  He repeated his call for dozens of new nuclear plants.  He also celebrated the soon-to-be-released Chevy Volt plug-in car.

One of McCain’s most well-received lines was his commitment to “secure our borders” when asked about a guest worker program.

McCain embraced charter and home schooling and any other educational vehicle that encourages choice and competition. 

One questioner challenged McCain’s “straight talk” persona and asked him to “tell us some things we don’t want to hear”.  The Senator pointed out his willingness to take on SecDef Rumsfeld in the wake of the initial Iraq invasion.  He also highlighted his opposition to ethanol even though it likely cost him the Iowa caucus.  He also told the audience that the West is in a long struggle against Islamic extremism and the U.S. can not shrink from the challenge.

One “undecided” voter who could only be undecided between McCain and a more conservative third party candidate asked McCain how conservatives could trust him.  The Senator pointed out distinct differences on taxes, health care, national security, and willingness to negotiate with terrorist states.  He concluded by saying Ronald Reagan would be a role model for his presidency. 

McCain expressed interest in Rep. Michele Bachmann’s plan for lowering gas prices and expressed his admiration for the Congresswoman.  He committed to much more frequent use of the prime time presidential address used with less frequency since Reagan.

The last question was from a man who expressed his admiration for Governor Pawlenty and said he would make a good vice president.  “What are his chances?”, the man asked.

 

(photo courtesy of Minnesota Democrats Exposed)

“Meeting adjourned!”, answered the nominee while expressing his admiration for the Governor who, he said, has “a place in the future of our country.”  Minnesota First Lady Mary Pawlenty, McCain noted, “is the brains of the outfit.”

Senator McCain is clearly at ease in the town hall format.  He comes across as knowledgeable, warm and sincere.  He is wise to seek to bring Senator Obama into this format as he would compare favorably in such circumstances. 

by @ 9:32 pm. Filed under Field Reports
Trackback URL for this post:
http://race42008.com/2008/06/19/race-4-2008-field-report-the-mccain-town-hall-in-st-paul/trackback/

13 Responses to “Race 4 2008 Field Report: The McCain Town Hall in St. Paul”

  1. Truth v. The Machine » Archives » At the McCain Town Hall in St. Paul Says:

    [...] Cross-posted at Race 4 2008. [...]

  2. Heath Says:

    How good is the $8 I got for T’Paw as the VP nom!

  3. MetroRepublican Says:

    A friend of the family was supposed to have a wedding reception at the Landmark tonight, and McCain booted them.

  4. Bob Says:

    #3, what is the point?

  5. MetroRepublican Says:

    1. It can be a small world. 2. Interesting to know Presidential campaigns can boot a long-established wedding date. Apparently if you’re a Presidential candidate, you don’t have to schedule around other people, you can schedule over them. I wonder if it takes winning a major party nomination to have that level of pull.

  6. Bryan Says:

    Hey Kavon i saw that McCain said at the Townhall that he would Reconsider Drilling In ANWR!! Is this true? This would make McCain look even better IMO. I know he would get hit for Flip-Flopping on off shore drilling he once opposed and drilling in ANWR. But the fact is sometimes politicians need to change their views when the country reaches dangerous times and the fact is that Americans want to drill and they want to drill now and if McCain say’s he will and Obama continues to sit on the sidelines and say nothing about it, then McCain will have a huge edge when it comes to Energy Policies.

  7. Aron Goldman Says:

    McCain Open to New Information on ANWR

  8. Bryan Says:

    Thanks for the info Aron!

  9. Greg Says:

    McCain has not real beliefs or convictions, other than the fact that he believes it was his birthright to be president despite never holding a real job and getting a military appointment because of his name. He’s just not that intelligent or knowledgable. Come on, we saw the debates. He has about two or three lines that he repeats again and again. Life-long republican here, but I can’t vote for this guy. I want someone of character. I don’t ever want this wing of the republican party to give me this type of candidate again. I mean, nobody is perfect, but I do have certain standards, and McCain is far below them.

    1.) Bad Family Man
    2.) Terrible Temper
    3.) No respect for people who disagree with him.
    4.) Uneducated on so many topics
    5.) So willing to change positions on topics he vehemently fought for.

    He’s just not a good person. Just ask the people he has belittled, bullied and insulted along the way.

  10. WiseGuy Says:

    9: Tell me why Obama is any better.

  11. Telamonian Aias Says:

    I won’t go as far as #9, but sheesh, is McCain going to stick by anything he said in the past? I actually favor opening ANWAR (mostly because I’ll never see it), but the man has opposed drilling there forever and to now turn on a dime simply for an election is disappointing. He is throwing away his reputation as a man of character.

  12. fredo Says:

    Hey Kavon and Gary:

    I was watching C-Span and caught Rep. Bachmann talking about energy policy. I guess that MN water is good for the constitution, eh?

  13. nowandlater Says:

    It’s good politics for McCain. He changed his position, but who is going to bash him when the
    public has had a massive change in opinion too. When the public goes from 30% for drilling to 70% drilling then how will it hurt him?

The Candidates

















Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

Featured Archives


Race 4 2008 Interviews

Search

Blogroll

Newswire

Get this widget!

Facebook


Join Race 4 2008 on Facebook

Site Syndication

RightRoots

Main

Meta Data

Design and Hosting By